Stage 4: Accomplished
Organization
Addresses the writing assignment analytically and perhaps imaginatively, with superior focus and coherence. Argument is developed cogently with a clear logical progression and little extraneous or irrelevant material. Demonstrates the ability to make highly effective use of feedback to revise writing.
Analysis and Insight
Demonstrates critical understanding and evaluation of sources through insightful analysis of relevant texts, data and evidence. Makes effective use of evidence to develop incisive arguments. Makes insightful connections to other's ideas, and integrates references to others' ideas smoothly.
Language and Mechanics
Demonstrates a sophisticated and nuanced use of language with effective variety in structure. Word choice is specific and precise. Grammar, usage and mechanics are handled with assurance. Fully integrates quotations and paraphrases in a manner appropriate to the assignment. Demonstrates distinctive style that is well-suited for the writer's subject and intention.
Disciplinary Conventions
Demonstrates use of discipline-specific research tools, and makes effective use of sources and formatting appropriate to the discipline. Confidently uses a structure and voice appropriate to the discipline. Writing reflects a critical engagement with key discourses in the discipline. Confidently and consistently uses citation appropriate for the discipline.